ATF results re: comparison of rubber gloves and fragments


August 20, 1971: ATF results on comparison of rubber gloves and fragments, p. 1 of 3

August 20, 1971: ATF results on comparison of rubber gloves and fragments, p. 2 of 3

August 20, 1971: ATF results on comparison of rubber gloves and fragments, p. 3 of 3

CID Findings


March 29, 1972:  USACIL Consolidated Report

USACIL Consolidated Report, page 21  Page 21
USACIL Consolidated Report, page 21


Paragraph 49:  Appropriate examinations of Exhibits E1, E2, E14, E15, E22, E117, E124, E129, E206, E211, E51MBR, E59NB, F60 and F115 were performed. These examinations did not reveal any data of significance or relevance.


USACIL Consolidated Report, page 23  Page 23
USACIL Consolidated Report, page 23


Paragraph 62:  h.  Exhibit E211 conained several pink nylon fibers and one (1) animal hair.

AFME Forensic Trace Materials Analysis Lab Report re: hair


Full transcript

November 30, 1999: AFME Forensic Trace Materials Analysis Lab Report, p. 2

DNA Findings


Full transcript (cover letter)
Full transcript (DNA Report)

Page 2:

The following samples yielded autosomal STR profiles consistent with one another:

AFDIL Specimen No. Specimen CID No., FBI No., or Reference
46A Hair Root E-211, Q125
98A Hair Root E-3, Q100.1
195A/195E/195J Paraffin Blocks Colette MacDonald Reference


Page 3:

The following samples yielded mitochondrial DNA sequences consistent with one another (Group A):

AFDIL Specimen No. Specimen CID No., FBI No., or Reference
46A Hair E-211, Q125
52A Hair E-4, Q118
71A(1) Vial Contents E-303, Q79
71A(3) Vial Contents E-303, Q79
97A(1) Vial Contents E-3, Q100
98A(1) Hair E-3, Q100.1
101A(1) Vial Contents E-205, Q89
101A(2) Vial Contents E-205, Q89
104A(2) Hair E-301, Q78
112A(4) Hair D-229, Q96.4
112A(5) Hair D-229, Q96.5
112A(7) Hair D-229, Q96.7
112A(9) Hair D-229, Q96.9
195A/195B Paraffin Blocks Colette MacDonald Reference
196A/196E2 Paraffin Blocks Kimberley MacDonald Reference
197A/197E Paraffin Blocks Kristen MacDonald Reference

Related exhibits

D211 Blue sheet bearing red-brown stains from floor of east bedroom
D245 Package containing surgeons gloves bearing red-brown stains from kitchen
I3 Suspected portion of surgical glove bearing red-brown stains from bed in east bedroom
I21 Suspected portion of surgical glove bearing red-brown stains from bedding on floor in east bedroom
I213 Suspected portion of surgical glove bearing red-brown stains from east bedroom
I226 Suspect portion of surgical glove bearing red-brown stains from Colette MacDonald's body

Webmaster note


With regard to pieces of latex rubber found in the master bedroom, many documents refer only to four pieces: Exhibit I3 (from the bed), Exhibit I21 (from the sheet on the floor), I213 (from near the dresser) and I226 (from the floor near Colette MacDonald's left elbow).

However, at trial on August 1, 1979, Craig Chamberlain (CID) testified that two pieces of a latex rubber glove were found in the sheet on the floor. The largest of these two pieces was found at the crime scene and was designated as I21. The other was found at the laboratory and was described as being in the vial of Exhibit E211 (although the CID findings for Exhibit E211 do not reflect this).

Hair from Colette MacDonald was also found in the debris from the sheet on the floor, but again the CID Findings do not show this. The hair is described in the AFME Forensic Trace Materials Analysis Lab Report (November 30, 1999) and in the DNA Report of March 10, 2006 as Specimen 46A.

See Friar's affidavit of February 8, 1991 and Malone's affidavit of February 13, 1991 in the Notes below for other findings from this exhibit which are not shown in either the CID Findings or the DNA Report. .


NOTES

February 17, 1970 - April 10, 1972: Excerpts from CID Reinvestigation    

April 6, 1970: Jeffrey MacDonald's CID interview with Grebner, Ivory and Shaw    

July 5, 1970: Pre-Article 32 defense questioning of Robert Shaw (CID)    

August 16, 1970: Jeffrey MacDonald at the Article 32 hearing    

October 13, 1970: Article 32 Investigating Officer Colonel Warren Rock's Report

August 20, 1971: ATF results re: comparison of rubber gloves and fragments    

June 26, 1973: Excerpts from U.S. Attorney McNamara's memo to the DOJ    

January 15, 1975: William Ivory (CID) at the Grand Jury

January 15, 1975: Discussion at the Grand Jury    

December 14, 1978: Memo from Brian Murtagh to Morris Clark (FBI)    

August 1, 1979: Craig Chamberlain (CID) at trial

August 6, 1979: Charles Hoffman (ATF) at trial    

August 24, 1979: Jeffrey MacDonald at trial    

August 28, 1979: Final arguments at trial

December 21, 1984: Defendant's Motion for Discovery and Inspection of Documents

May 31, 1985: Excerpt from Brief of Appellant to the U.S. Fourth Circuit

December 17, 1985: Excerpt from U. S. 4th Circuit Court of Appeals

October 13, 1990: Excerpt from Affidavit of Bernard Segal

October 16, 1990: Excerpt from Affidavit of John Murphy

February 8, 1991: Affidavit of James Frier (FBI)    

February 14, 1991: Affidavit of Michael Malone (FBI)    

November 30, 1999: AFME Forensic Trace Materials Analysis Lab Report re: hair      

March 10, 2006: DNA Report    

March 15, 2006: Gov't Response to Defense Contentions re: DNA Testing      

February 19, 2009: Excerpt from defense's corrected motion for appeal